Understanding The Key Differences Between Slate And Asphalt Roofing


When you find yourself in need of a new roof for the home you are planning to build, you will be faced with a wide variety of choices and options. There are numerous different materials that can be made into roofing, including some as wacky as old vinyl records and license plates. However, if a traditional-style roof is what you are looking for, then you may have narrowed your decision down to slate roofing or asphalt shingles. Get to know some of the differences between the two and how they compare so you can decide which roofing material is right for your brand new home.

Comparing The Environmental Impact Of The Materials

Slate is a natural stone (rock) that can be shaved down and shaped into roofing shingles. It is not a man-made material. On the other hand, asphalt is a petroleum based product that combines several different aggregates, binders, and fillers to create the product.

As such, if you are environmentally-conscious, the creation of new asphalt shingles is far more energy-intensive than harvesting and cutting slate into roof shingles. Slate roofing requires less energy to create and therefore could be considered the much more energy efficient option. It is also important to note, however, that both types of roofs can be recycled and reused if you want to purchase materials that are recycled, which can offset any environmental impact.

Understanding The Difference In Costs

Slate roofing, because it is a heavier material and a natural stone, is often quite a bit more expensive in both the materials and labor costs for installation. This type of roof can cost anywhere from $9 to $40 per square foot (including labor and materials) depending on your type of roof and the exact style of slate that you choose.

Asphalt shingle roofs are significantly less expensive than a slate roof. The costs of both labor and the materials for an asphalt shingle roof are around $1 to $4 per square foot on average. This is because asphalt shingles are much lighter weight and use man-made materials that are less expensive than standard natural stone.

Knowing How Long Your Roof Can Last

When it comes to your roof's longevity, asphalt shingles simply cannot compete with the durability of slate roofing. Slate roofing can last over a century if well-maintained and taken care of. This is because the earth takes hundreds or thousands of years just to create these types of stones. They are made to last.

Asphalt shingles, for their part, can last several decades if you make sure to perform regular and routine maintenance. However, because they are lighter and more susceptible to damage from the elements, they cannot compare to slate shingle roofs.

Now that you know more about some of the key differences between slate roofing and asphalt shingle roofing, you can make the best choice for you and the home you will soon be building. For more information, visit sites like http://www.threeriversroofing.com/.

About Me

Tracking Down Roofing Problems

A few years ago, our roof started to have all kinds of problems. The shingles were perpetually blowing off, and I could tell that there were some underlying rot issues. We could see mold and moss from street level, and so I called in the professionals. Our professional roofing team took the time to get up on the roof, inspect the damage, and recommend repairs. They were incredibly easy to work with, and I was really impressed by their professionalism. This blog is all about things to look for when it comes to your roof and tips for finding an incredible roofer.